Ernst Matscheko
Professor Mark Jeffreys
INTS-3900-01
2 December 2013
Do
neighborhoods have to die, before they will be resuscitated?
Right in front
of our own eyes, neighborhoods have been transformed by history and profound
demographic change; neighborhoods had been “removed”, thousands of families
were displaced, and buildings demolished – neighborhoods had been radically and
purposely reshaped by governmental intervention. Neighborhoods, or communities
as we know them are disappearing, but not for good, they are just forced to
move to a different geographic location. The damaged community they left behind
is then eradicated and a new physical infrastructure and housing is created. Wherever
the “displaced” are going, they take the “ghetto” with them and they are not
better off – the neighborhood they left behind may be. We need to understand
that physical infrastructure and housing are crucial, but so is social
infrastructure. To simply move people out of targeted communities is not the
answer, but investing in communities on the edge, may be. We need to reduce the
risk of future violence and at the same time promote and sustain community’s
collective efficacy. In this paper, I will apply the tools of my emphasis
business management as well as recreation management to save neighborhoods; I
will demonstrate how to prevent neighborhood crime, rebuild neighborhoods’
physical, social, and economic infrastructure, and equally important how to find
financial resources to pay for all that.
The
future of old neighborhoods
The
deterioration of downtown urban areas that have not become slums has attracted
the attention of urban planners. The proposed solution is, therefore, similar
to the one that is given for slums: rehabilitation, change before urban blight
eats up the whole downtown neighborhood, and speed in executing it. The present
volume takes a different line. Granting that the "old neighborhoods"
do not have ideal living conditions, they could be made into quite reasonable
dwelling areas. Moreover, he shows the original valuable function of these old
neighborhoods, namely, as the first step of low-income households. They form a
ready market for dwellings in these neighborhoods; not only that, they can
afford only this type of dwelling. If it is not available, these groups will
get worse housing or they will become dependent on public funds. Although we
might want to see, in most of our cities, an ultimately rebuilt downtown area
with civic centers, luxury apartments, and business buildings, this cannot be
done overnight. And in the meantime, the dwellings are needed and the
structures are standing. For the foreseeable future, say ten to twenty years,
it might be more sensible to keep these areas for a reasonable dwelling
function for low-income households instead of either letting them degenerate
into slums or tearing them down without any replacement or equivalent housing
(Back 572). Households in low-income neighborhoods, by themselves, often do not
have the resources to meet the multitude of daily needs, and they are forced to
seek help from others to meet these needs. Typically, government, private
organizations, or religious institutions have provided support encumbered with
rules and regulations designed to identify and assist the "worthy"
poor. This approach to social service has not solved the problems of poverty
and may actually work to sustain system dependency while undermining the sense
of self-worth of individuals living in low-income neighborhoods. In contrast,
programs that promote community participation and indigenous leadership and
empower decision-making processes may provide more sustainable positive
outcomes for families living in low-income neighborhoods. Indeed, families from
some low-income neighborhoods have successfully mobilized their resources and
used their collective power to influence the direction and decisions affecting
their neighborhoods or communities (Brisson 644).
Richmond,
VA leads by example
Richmond’s Mayor
Dwight C. Jones has an ambitious — some say quixotic — plan to subdue poverty
in this city, one of the nation’s poorest urban areas. Emphasizing programs the
city can afford on its $760 million budget, Richmond is considering pairing
every at-risk child ages 11 to 15 with an adult mentor; razing public housing
and replacing it with mixed-income units with the option of homeownership;
setting up an intensive manufacturing training program that would give the
unemployed the skills needed to work at one of the many local companies looking
for workers; starting a farm-to-school program to promote adequate nutrition;
and establishing an assistance program to help pay water and wastewater bills
for low-income households (Williams A15).
There is no crime in neighborhood
Every
neighborhood has a unique geography. Research suggests that crime and
residents' perceptions of crime are strongly linked to this underlying
geography. Neighborhoods serve as geographical frames of reference,
encompassing the demographic, economic and ecologic characteristics of a
particular place. Members of a community frame their sense of neighborhood
using geographic markers such as streets, buildings or natural land formations
as boundaries. Consequently, their community-based efforts — centered on what
is meaningful to them, such as health, housing, schools, jobs, services and
crime — occur within those boundaries. This proximity connects community
members to the same – good or bad - experiences and both geography and social
interaction help form collective identity.
Blighted and deteriorated
neighborhoods are associated with crime.
Controlling the physical
deterioration in a neighborhood by limiting graffiti, trash accumulation and
other signs of distress in public areas and on personal property can influence
a potential offender's perception of an area's vulnerability to crime. It can
also influence residents' fear of crime. Also, the layouts of low-crime
neighborhoods often have more one-way, narrow and low-volume streets, which
make entry more difficult. This includes giving careful attention to walkways,
paths, streets, traffic patterns, and the location and hours of operation of
public spaces and facilities (Wilson). In addition, local non-profit
organizations such as Cure Violence may help in eradication of crime. Cure
Violence reverses the spread of violence by using the methods and strategies
associated with disease control—detection and interruption, identifying
individuals involved in transmission, and changing social norms of the
communities where it occurs. Los Angeles Chief of Police, Charlie Beck has this
to say: “If you are willing to use resources other than traditional law
enforcement - whether interrupters, intervention workers or school-based
programs - then you can change a neighborhood (Cure Violence).
Business
management’s role in restructuring
This is the best
part; I will create a thrift store that will fully operate on donations. How is
that going to work? It’s simple, I place donation containers in all parts of
town and will offer free pickup of items no longer wanted or needed in the
“upscale” or “better” neighborhoods. According to IRS publication 526, the
donations will be tax-deductible and we will offer donation receipts for
donors’ tax records. In my store I will offer a wide variety of used and new
items. You'll find thousands of articles of used clothing and household items
as well as a wide variety of furniture. I will also offer a selection of new
items such as socks, underwear, bedding, and towels and all items will be
offered at affordable prices. The sales revenue I will for my internal a job
training and placement program. My program will help employees to gain valuable
work experience, successful work skills, and will offer a variety of training
opportunities. In addition, I will partner with community colleges, applied
technology centers, and other institutions that offer training courses in
accounting, information technology, health care, and other areas to my
qualifying employees (Deseret Industries).
Finally,
the recreation management specialist’s solution
The Trust for
Public Land recently published a report that reveals an inexorable link between
crime and urban neglect. Entitled "Healing America's Cities: Why We Must
Invest in Urban Parks," the report uses facts and figures from studies
based on recreation and land conservation programs initiated in cities across
the nation. The evidence is revealing and builds a case for the vital
importance of parks and recreation in our communities. Congressman Bruce Vento
(D-Minn.) is among an increasing number of political leaders and community
activists who insist that perhaps there is a better way to fight crime.
"Urban recreation and sports programs are a proven, common sense, and
cost-effective means of preventing crime and delinquency," he says.
"I wonder if our urban youth crime rate would be different if these
programs had not been neglected in the past." Vento is cosponsoring
legislation to provide crime prevention funds for parks and recreation
facilities because, Vento says, "Without accessible and well-maintained
places to recreate, there can be no recreation." In 1991, 75% of the
children enrolled in STARS (Success Through Academics and Recreational support)
were making less than a C average in school. Now 80% of the 1,500 children
enrolled have brought their grades up to a C average or better. The U.S.
Departments of Interior and Justice are using the same concept for a Youth
Environmental Service (YES) program that began in 1994: employing delinquent
and at-risk teens to do environmental conservation work on federal lands. Three
pilot programs are underway. In Utah, moderate offenders will be bused from
Salt Lake City to work on Bureau of Land Management property where they will
spend as long as 30 days in wilderness areas. At the Big Cypress National
Preserve and Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge in Florida, serious and
violent juvenile offenders will live and work near conservation areas, and in
Washington, D.C., juvenile offenders will help the National Park Service
maintain the national park and monuments within the city (Healing America’s
Cities: Why We Must Invest in Urban Parks).
How
are we going to pay for it?
In 1990,
Congress created the EB-5, Immigrant Investor Program, intended to stimulate
the U.S. economy through job creation and capital investment by foreign
investors. Under this program international individuals who wish to receive an
immigrant visa, must either create or preserve at least 10 full-time jobs for
qualifying U.S. workers or invest a minimum of $500.000 within a
high-unemployment (at least 150% of the national rate) area or rural area in
the United States. Such investment can come in form cash, equipment, inventory,
other tangible property, cash equivalents and indebtedness secured by assets
owned by the alien entrepreneur (EB-5 Immigrant Investor).
It's a sunny
Wednesday afternoon, the time of day when the streets of the Stony Point
subdivision should be bustling with kids returning home from school. But what
was once a thriving suburban neighborhood now looks more like a ghost town,
with empty cardboard boxes rolling down the driveways like tumbleweed in the
wind. There's not much left of the neighborhood many have called home for years
(Allday A1). Sounds familiar? Neighborhoods are not just geographic features,
they are as a resource for ethnic identity formation and collective mobilization.
Neighborhoods represent urban spaces through which a range of bonding social
capital resources are generated including ties of reciprocal trust, solidarity
and civic participation. These urban spaces also hold intrinsic value in the
lives of young people, providing them with a sense of wellbeing and belonging.
This is despite the apparent problems of socioeconomic disadvantage, social
inequality and exclusion that are typically associated with low-income neighborhoods’
life—such as within the education system, the labor market and the criminal
justice system (Reynolds 484). But change is near; all we need to do is
identify neighborhoods in need, identify and eliminate the “playgrounds” for
crime, invite the “big spender” from foreign lands to the neighborhood, rebuilt
the neighborhoods’ physical, social, economic infrastructure, and return the
neighborhood to its people.
Works Cited
Allday, Erin. "SR Neighborhood Desolate; Most Tenants
Gone, Holdouts Missing Community." The Press Democrat [Santa Rosa,
CA] 02 May 2002: A1. ProQuest Newsstand. Web. 2 Dec. 2013.
Back, Kurt W. "Book Review:The Future of Old
Neighborhoods: Rebuilding for a Changing Population. Bernard J. Frieden." American
Journal of Sociology 71.5 (1966): 572-73. Print.
Brisson, Daniel S., and Charles L. Usher. "Bonding
Social Capital in Low-Income Neighborhoods." Family Relations. 5th
ed. Vol. 54. N.p.: Blackwell, 2005. 644-53. Print.
"Cure Violence." Cure Violence. N.p., n.d.
Web. 30 Nov. 2013.
"Deseret Industries Thrift Store | Deseret
Industries." Deseret Industries. N.p., n.d. Web. 02 Dec. 2013.
"EB-5 Immigrant Investor." U.S. Citizenship and
Immigration Services. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, 3 July 2012.
Web. 23 Nov. 2013.
"Healing America's Cities: Why We Must Invest in Urban
Parks." Healing America's Cities: Why We Must Invest in Urban Parks.
Illinois State Library, Jan.-Feb. 1995. Web. 11 Oct. 2013.
Reynolds, Tracey. ""Them and Us": "Black
Neighborhoods" as a Social Capital Resource among Black Youth Living in
Inner-city London." Urban Studies 50.3 (2013): 484-98. Sage.
Web. 2 Dec. 2013.
Williams, Timothy. "Richmond Awaits a Bold Antipoverty
Plan." The New York Times [New York] 15 Oct. 2013: A15+. The New
York Times. The New York Times, 15 Oct. 2013. Web. 30 Nov. 2013.
Wilson, Ronald E., Timothy H. Brown, and Beth Schuster.
"Preventing Neighborhood Crime: Geography Matters." NIJ Journal
263 (2009): n. pag. NIJ Home Page. U.S. Department of Justice, 15 June
2009. Web. 15 Sept. 2013.
No comments:
Post a Comment